KöMaL - Középiskolai Matematikai és Fizikai Lapok
Sign In
Sign Up


Problem A. 543. (October 2011)

A. 543. The sum of the probabilities of some (finitely many) independent events is 4. Prove that with probability higher than 1/2, the number of occurred events is congruent to 0 or 3 modulo 4.

(Suggested by Endre Csóka, Budapest)

(5 pont)

Deadline expired on 10 November 2011.

Solution. Let the probabilities be p1,...,pn, where p1+...+pn=4. Let xj=1 if the jth event occurs, otherwise let xj=0. Let N=x1+...+xn be the number of occuring events and let q_r = P\Big(N\equiv r\pmod4 \Big) (r=0,1,2,3). We have to show that q0+q3>q1+q2.

Consider the random complex number S=iN. This number is respectively 1, i, -1 or -i, if the remainder of N modulo 4 is 0, 1, 2, or 3.



the statement is equivalent to

-\frac\pi4 < \arg S < \frac{3\pi}4. (1)

By the definition of S we have

S = i^N = i^{x_1+\dots+x_n} = \prod_{j=1}^n i^{x_j}
= \prod_{j=1}^n \Big((1-x_j)+x_ji\Big).

The factors on the right-hand side are independent, so

E(S) = \prod_{j=1}^n E\Big((1-x_j)+x_ji\Big)
= \prod_{j=1}^n \Big((1-p_j)+p_ji\Big).

Let \varphi=\mathrm{arg}(p_j+(1-p_j)i) (0\le\varphi_j\le\frac\pi2). To prove (1) it is sufficient to prove

 \frac54\pi < \varphi_1+\dots+\varphi_n < \frac94\pi. (2)

Leet f(t)=\arctan\frac{t}{1-t} if 0\let<1 and let f(1)=\lim_{t\to1-0}f(1)=\frac\pi2. Then \varphij=f(pj) for every j. We show that

 t \le f(t) \le \frac{49}{29}t. (3)

From this (2) immediately follows because

\varphi_1+\dots+\varphi_n = f(p_1)+\dots+f(p_n) \ge p_1+\dots+p_n = 4 >\frac54\pi,


\varphi_1+\dots+\varphi_n = f(p_1)+\dots+f(p_n) \le \frac{49}{29}(p_1+\dots+p_n) = \frac{49}{29}\cdot 4 < \frac94\pi.

Let g(t)=f(t)-t. For 0<t<1 we have g'(t)=f'(t)-1=\frac{2t(1-t)}{1-2t(1-t)}>0, the function g increases. Therefore, g(t)\geg(0)=0 and f(t)\get.

Now consider the function h(t)=f(t)-\frac{49}{29}t. Since h'(t)=f'(t)-\frac{49}{29}=-\frac{2(7t-2)(7t-5)}{29(1-2t(1-t))}, we have h'<0 in the intervals (0,2/7) and (5/7,1), and we have h'>0 in the interval (2/7,5/7). Therefore, h decreases in [0,2/7] and [5/7,1], and increases in [2/7,5/7]. Since h(0)=0 and h(5/7)=\arctan\frac52-\frac{49}{29}\cdot\frac57\aprox-0,0166<0, it follows that h is never positive, so h(t)\le0 and hence f(t)\le\frac{49}{29}t.


6 students sent a solution.
5 points:Ágoston Tamás, Gyarmati Máté, Omer Cerrahoglu, Strenner Péter.
3 points:1 student.
2 points:1 student.

Our web pages are supported by:   Ericsson   Cognex   Emberi Erőforrás Támogatáskezelő   Emberi Erőforrások Minisztériuma   Nemzeti Tehetség Program    
MTA Energiatudományi Kutatóközpont   MTA Wigner Fizikai Kutatóközpont     Nemzeti
Kulturális Alap   ELTE   Morgan Stanley